AEM Podcast #80 Paul Hughes What's Not Working in Modern Education & What We Can Do - Academies | OFSTED

An Evolving Man Podcast (AEM) #80 Paul Hughes | What’s Not Working in Modern Education – And How We Can Fix It

In this powerful conversation, I speak with Paul Hughes, former teacher, department head, and co-founder of Parent Guide to GCSE, about what’s really happening inside the modern education system — and how we can start to fix it.

Paul spent over sixteen years teaching, initially loving the profession. But after the rise of academisation and years of austerity, he saw the culture of education shift from caring about students to chasing targets and cutting costs.


“It went from being all about the students to all about the bottom line,” Paul explains.

From Passion to Pressure: The Changing Face of Teaching


When schools were converted into academies, Paul witnessed firsthand how bureaucracy, financial constraints, and endless inspections drained the joy and creativity out of teaching.
Funding cuts meant fewer resources, larger class sizes, and even school trips being cancelled because the bus couldn’t be afforded.


Teachers lost autonomy. Arts and sports — the soul of a child’s education — were pushed aside for exam-driven performance metrics.

“We used to take students to forests for team-building. Then to the park. Then… we couldn’t afford to go anywhere.”

Ofsted and the Culture of Fear


One of Paul’s most passionate points is about Ofsted, which he calls “the Office for Terrorising Teachers.”


He describes how the inspection system creates fear, damages morale, and focuses on one-day snapshots instead of genuine learning and well-being.


A single negative mark can devastate a teacher’s confidence — or even a whole school’s reputation.


The Mental-Health Crisis in Students


Beyond teachers, students themselves are struggling.


Underfunded schools often lack the support staff, counsellors, and resources to help children with trauma, ADHD, or special educational needs.


Paul shares how many children now face chaotic home lives, bullying, hunger, or anxiety before even entering the classroom — and teachers are expected to cope without adequate support.


Private vs. State: The Inequality Gap


Paul and I also explore the growing divide between private and state education.


In private schools, annual spending can exceed £18,000 per pupil, compared to around £5,500 in state schools.


That difference shows up everywhere — from sports facilities to arts programs to mental-health provision.


As Paul puts it:

“The opportunities are just not comparable. It’s not just maths and English that make an education — it’s everything on the periphery that makes people who they are.”

What Needs to Change


Paul believes the future of education depends on:

  • Reforming Ofsted to prioritise learning and well-being over data and fear
  • Fair funding that restores arts, sport, and special-needs provision
  • Improved teacher pay and retention to rebuild morale and continuity
  • More parent involvement and emotional literacy in schools
  • Equality of access — because education should be a right, not a privilege

He also advocates for greater father engagement and family connection, both at home and in schools, to support teenagers emotionally and academically.


A Hopeful Future



Despite the challenges, Paul remains hopeful.
Through Parent Guide to GCSE, he and his wife Emily are helping parents better support their teenagers — offering resources, mentoring, and guidance through the stress of exams and adolescence.

“We can’t fix the system overnight,” he says. “But we can help parents and students navigate it better — and that’s where change begins.”


eldership in leadership
By piers February 13, 2026
What if leadership fails because of ungrieved trauma? A CLG reflection on eldership, emotional intelligence, and healing cultures shaped by institutions.
By piers February 6, 2026
Charles Spencer speaks openly about boarding school abuse, fear, rage, corporal punishment, and lifelong trauma. A vital conversation about silence, survival, and truth.
By piers January 30, 2026
A powerful conversation with paediatrician Dr William Verling on boarding school trauma, safeguarding failures, emotional shutdown, impostor syndrome, and what happens when children aren’t protected.
By piers January 23, 2026
A deep conversation with Dr Mark Stibbe on the mother wound, attachment theory, and why boarding school can create emotional shutdown. Plus Skyfall, James Bond, and healing pathways.
By piers January 16, 2026
Actor and comedian Tom Greaves shares how boarding school shaped his humour, shame, and identity — and how his show “Goodbye Uncle Fudgy” became a path from dissociation to healing.
By piers January 9, 2026
Educational psychologist Morag Edwards explores girls’ boarding school trauma, neglect, attachment rupture, and misogyny in co-educational boarding schools.
By piers January 2, 2026
Sam Adams explores men’s trauma, emotional shutdown, and how reconnecting with nature, seasons, and community can heal the wounded masculine.
By piers December 26, 2025
Dr Mark Stibbe shares how boarding school abuse shaped his emotional shutdown (“the boarded heart”), and how therapy, spirituality, and forgiveness can lead to healing.
By piers December 19, 2025
Roger Sharpley shares the lifelong impact of being sent to boarding school at age two, including PTSD, memory loss, anxiety, and healing through therapy, Tai Chi, and love.
By piers December 12, 2025
Andrew Kavak shares his Westminster School boarding experience, the psychology of abandonment and dissociation, and how writing therapy can support healing. Listen to Episode 84 of An Evolving Man Podcast.