The Brutal Inner Critic of the Boarding School Survivor

There is a voice I hear surprisingly often in my work with former boarders.

It says:

You’re weak.

You should have done better.

What’s wrong with you?

You’re not good enough.

Sometimes it is so familiar that the person does not even recognise it as an inner critic.

They simply assume:

“That’s how I motivate myself.”

I understand this because for many years I had an extraordinarily brutal inner voice of my own.

And recently, a dream helped me understand something about where it came from.

“The more brutal we are with ourselves, the more people leave us alone”

In the dream, I was explaining boarding school to a woman.

I heard myself say:

“The more brutal we are with ourselves, the more people leave us alone.”

Then:

“If we’re not brutal with ourselves, the teachers and the people in the dormitory will be brutal to us.”

When I woke up, those words stayed with me.

Because psychologically, they made sense.

I remembered arriving at boarding school and being humiliated by the other boys when I cried.

I made a decision:

That is never happening again.

So when emotion appeared, I began policing it myself.

Tears?

“You idiot.”

Fear?

“You’re weak.”

Homesickness?

“Get over it.”

The external bully gradually became internal.

If I attack myself first, I keep control

There is a strange logic to severe self-criticism.

If I hurt myself first, nobody else gets there before me.

I retain control.

If thirty children might humiliate me for appearing vulnerable, perhaps I can prevent that by eliminating the vulnerability myself.

I harden my face.

Stop crying.

Become tougher.

Attack weakness before anybody else sees it.

For a child in a threatening environment, that strategy may make considerable sense.

It is protective.

The problem is that we then leave school—but the voice comes with us.

The boarding house disappears.

The inner boarding house remains.

The inner critic can look like high performance

This is where things become particularly interesting.

A brutal inner critic does not always produce obvious dysfunction.

Sometimes it produces extraordinary achievement.

We tell ourselves:

Work harder.

Be better.

Don’t make mistakes.

Second isn’t good enough.

I remember being one of the best sprinters at my school.

Then I competed at county level and came fifth.

Rather than recognising:

“I’m one of the fastest young runners in the county,”

my mind went to:

“Not good enough.”

The benchmark simply moved.

This is why perfectionism and achievement can become so closely connected to boarding school survival.

The critic pushes.

And sometimes the pushing works.

Until it doesn't.

Elite performance does not require self-hatred

One of the things that has surprised me as I have studied leadership and peak performance is how often elite performers talk about the importance of a constructive internal voice.

Former Navy SEALs and performance writers describe self-leadership not as continually abusing yourself, but as learning how to direct yourself.

That distinction matters.

There is a difference between:

“Come on, Piers. You’ve got this.”

and:

“You useless idiot. Don’t mess this up.”

Both may create action.

But they create very different internal environments.

One is leadership.

The other is intimidation.

Would you lead another person like this?

Perhaps this is an interesting question for leaders.

Imagine speaking to a member of your team in exactly the same way you speak to yourself.

Would you call them pathetic?

Tell them nothing they do is enough?

Remind them continually of every mistake?

Tell them everybody else is better?

Would that create sustainable high performance?

Probably not.

Yet many highly successful people run exactly this leadership system internally.

We talk about compassionate leadership towards others.

Perhaps one of the first people we have to learn to lead compassionately is ourselves.

The inner critic is often young

One practice I find useful is to stop assuming that the inner critic represents some mature authority.

Listen carefully.

How old does it actually feel?

Often I experience these critical parts as surprisingly young.

Eight.

Nine.

Ten.

Eleven.

They developed when we needed them.

The temptation is then to attack the critic.

“Shut up.”

“Go away.”

But that can become another version of the same system.

Another part of ourselves being bullied.

I find it more useful to think in terms of parenting.

Becoming the benevolent parent

If a frightened five-year-old tries to run into a road, a healthy parent does not simply let them.

But neither do they necessarily scream:

“You stupid child!”

They can be firm:

“No. I’m not letting you do that.”

And loving:

“I’ve got you.”

That is increasingly how I work with my own inner critic.

When it arrives:

No.

Enough.

I understand that you’re frightened.

But we’re not speaking to ourselves like that anymore.

Firmness and compassion together.

Thought correction

Pete Walker writes about challenging the catastrophising and perfectionistic programming of the inner critic.

I find it useful to have alternative phrases prepared.

Mine might be:

“You’ve got this.”

Or:

“I’m doing wonderfully well.”

This is not pretending everything is perfect.

It is directing the mind.

A useful distinction I came across in performance psychology is:

Don’t only listen to yourself. Talk to yourself.

We cannot necessarily stop every negative thought appearing.

But we can decide whether it gets to lead.

The body matters too

For former boarders, this work cannot always remain purely cognitive.

The inner critic was often created alongside embodied fear.

Humiliation.

Homesickness.

Grief.

Loneliness.

So sometimes thought correction needs to be accompanied by soothing the nervous system.

Breathing.

Touch.

Havening.

Feeling the feet.

Slowing down.

And sometimes crying.

Grief softened my inner critic

This was certainly important in my own life.

In my twenties, my inner critic became so severe that at times I externalised that violence and harmed myself.

The voice inside became something I enacted physically.

A major shift began when I started to reconnect with grief.

Living in a Buddhist monastery, I began crying.

Really crying.

Feeling what I had not allowed myself to feel.

And gradually, something changed.

The brutality diminished.

I no longer needed to attack myself in order to survive the emotion.

I could feel it.

And let it move.

I have not self-harmed for more than two decades.

That experience taught me something important:

Sometimes the inner critic becomes louder because another part of us is desperate not to feel.

From inner bully to inner leader

Nick Duffell has written about how former boarders can carry both a wounded younger part and an internalised adult or authority figure that becomes an inner bully.

That description resonates deeply with me.

The task is not to destroy the younger part.

And perhaps it is not even to destroy the bully.

It is to bring in a different internal authority.

A compassionate adult.

A benevolent parent.

An inner leader.

Someone who can say:

I see that you’re frightened.

I understand why you learned this.

But you don’t need to attack us anymore.

I’ve got this now.

That, to me, is part of healing boarding school syndrome.

Not becoming soft.

Not abandoning standards.

But discovering that cruelty towards ourselves was never the only route to excellence.

And perhaps, ultimately, kindness creates a much more sustainable form of performance anyway.

Watch the full episode here: